Comparative Analysis of Navia and Zerodha: A Detailed Blog
In the rapidly evolving world of online trading, selecting the right broker can significantly impact your trading experience and overall profitability. Navia and Zerodha are two prominent players in the Indian brokerage market, each offering a range of services tailored to different types of investors and Traders. In this blog, we will compare these two brokers based on various parameters.
Comparative Table: Navia vs. Zerodha
| PARAMETERS | NAVIA | ZERODHA |
|---|---|---|
| TERMINALS | ||
| Web Platform | Navia Web | Kite |
| Desktop Platform | Navia EXE | NA |
| Mobile Platform | Navia APP | Kite mobile |
| Algo Platform | Navia API | Kite API |
| SUPPORT | ||
| Website | Visit | Visit |
| Support Articles | Visit | Visit |
| Email Support – Tickets | Portal Support – Tickets | Portal Support – Tickets |
| SMS | No | No |
| Yes | No | |
| Live Chat | Yes | No |
| 24/7/365 Chat Bot | Yes | No |
| PRICING | ||
| Account Opening Charges | Zero | Zero |
| AMC | Zero | ₹300/year + GST |
| Equity Delivery | Zero | Zero |
| Equity Intraday | Zero | Lower of 0.03% or ₹20 |
| Futures | Zero | Lower of 0.03% or ₹20 |
| Options | Zero | Flat ₹20 |
| MTF Interest Rate | From 14.99% | Does not provide MTF |
| MTF Pledge/Unpledge Charges | Higher of 0.02% or ₹50 | Does not provide MTF |
| Direct Mutual Funds | Zero | Zero |
| Call & Trade Services | ₹50 + GST | ₹50 + GST |
| Admin Square Off Charges | ₹50 + GST | ₹50 + GST |
| DP Sell Charges | ₹30 + GST | ₹13 + GST |
| Payment Gateway Charges – UPI | Zero | Zero |
| Payment Gateway Charges – Net Banking | ₹9 + GST | ₹9 + GST |
| Pledge / Unpledge Charges | Higher of 0.02% or ₹50 | ₹30 + GST |
| API Monthly Subscription Charges | ₹1500 + GST | ₹2000 + GST |
| PRODUCTS | ||
| Equity | Yes | Yes |
| Intraday | Yes | Yes |
| Futures | Yes | Yes |
| Options | Yes | Yes |
| Commodities | Yes | Yes |
| Currencies | No | Yes |
| Margin Trade Funding | Yes | No |
| ETF | Yes | Yes |
| Direct Mutual Funds | Yes | Yes |
| IPO | Yes | Yes |
| Bonds | Yes | Yes |
| Insurance | No | Through Ditto |
| PMS/Advisory Services | No | Through Smallcase |
| US Stocks | Yes | No |
| OTHER FEATURES | ||
| Watchlists | 5 | 8 |
| Market Depth | 5 ask and bid prices | 20 ask and bid prices |
| Indicators | 100+ | 100+ |
| Type of Charts | 11 | 11 |
| Option Chain | Yes | Yes |
| Free Option Strategy Builder | Yes | Through Sensibull |
| Results Calendar | Yes | No |
| Orders on Charts | Yes | Yes |
| Profit and Loss on Charts | No | No |
| Technical Analysis | Yes | Yes |
| Fundamental Analysis | Yes | Through Tickertape |
| Research | No | No |
| Price Alert | Yes | Yes |
| Free Ready-made ETF Baskets | Yes | No |
| Free Custom ETF Baskets | Yes | No |
| TYPE OF ORDERS | ||
| CNC | Yes | Yes |
| Intraday | Yes | Yes |
| BO | No | No |
| CO | No | No |
| MTF | Yes | No |
| Basket Order | Yes | Yes |
| AMO | Yes | Yes |
| GTT | Yes | Yes |
| Single Square Off Button | Yes | Yes |
| Multi-Select Square Off Button | Yes | Yes |
| Share Screen Option | Yes | No |
| MARGINS | ||
| Equity Intraday | 5X | 5X |
| Equity Delivery | 1X | 1X |
| Option Buying | 1X | 1X |
| Futures Buy/Sell + Option Sell | SPAN + Additional + exposure | SPAN + Additional + exposure |
| Hedge Benefit | Yes | Yes |
| MTF | 3X | Does not Provide |
Summary of the Findings
From the comparison table above, it is clear that both Navia and Zerodha offer a range of services and products to cater to different types of investors. However, there are several key areas where Navia stands out and offers distinct advantages over Zerodha.
Navia’s Zero Brokerage Benefits: A Key Advantage Over Zerodha
One of the most significant advantages that Navia offers to traders and investors is its zero brokerage policy. This feature sets Navia apart from many of its competitors, including Zerodha, and provides substantial cost savings for clients. Let’s delve into how Navia’s zero brokerage benefits can positively impact your trading experience and overall profitability.
What is Zero Brokerage?
Zero brokerage means that traders and investors are not charged any brokerage fees on their trades, whether it’s for equity delivery, intraday trading, futures, or options. Instead of paying a percentage or a flat fee for each transaction, Navia clients can trade without worrying about accumulating brokerage costs, which can add up significantly over time.
Key Areas Where Navia Offers Zero Brokerage
Equity Delivery
Navia: Zero brokerage on all equity delivery trades.
Zerodha: Zero brokerage on equity delivery as well.
Benefit: For long-term investors, this means that you can buy and hold stocks without any additional costs, allowing your investments to grow unencumbered by brokerage fees.
Equity Intraday
Navia: Zero brokerage on intraday trades.
Zerodha: Charges the lower of 0.03% or ₹20 per trade.
Benefit: Active traders can execute numerous intraday trades without worrying about brokerage fees eating into their profits. This is particularly beneficial for scalpers or day traders who make multiple trades within a single trading session.
Futures Trading
Navia: Zero brokerage on futures trading.
Zerodha: Charges the lower of 0.03% or ₹20 per trade.
Benefit: Futures traders, who often engage in larger contract sizes, can benefit from significant cost savings, as they do not have to pay any brokerage fees on their trades.
Options Trading
Navia: Zero brokerage on options trading.
Zerodha: Charges a flat ₹20 per order.
Benefit: Options traders can enhance their profitability by avoiding the flat fee typically charged per trade by other brokers. This is especially advantageous for traders who employ strategies involving multiple legs, such as spreads, straddles, or strangles.
Direct Mutual Funds
Navia: Zero brokerage on direct mutual fund investments.
Zerodha: Also offers zero brokerage on direct mutual funds.
Benefit: Investors can build their mutual fund portfolio without any additional costs, ensuring that all their investments go directly into the funds rather than being reduced by brokerage fees.
How Zero Brokerage Translates to Real Savings
To illustrate the impact of zero brokerage, let’s consider an example:
⮞ Scenario 1: A trader executes 50 intraday trades in a month with an average trade value of ₹2,00,000 per trade.
Zerodha’s Cost: Assuming the lower of 0.03% or ₹20, the trader would pay ₹1,000 in brokerage fees.
Navia’s Cost: Zero brokerage means the trader pays ₹0 in brokerage fees.
Savings: The trader saves ₹1,000 in a single month, which can be reinvested or contribute to overall profitability.
⮞ Scenario 2: An options trader executes 100 orders in a month.
Zerodha’s Cost: ₹20 per order results in ₹2,000 in brokerage fees.
Navia’s Cost: Zero brokerage means the trader pays ₹0 in brokerage fees.
Savings: The trader saves ₹2,000, which could be significant over a longer period, especially for active options traders.
Advantages of Zero Brokerage with Navia
🔸 Increased Profitability: By eliminating brokerage fees, more of your profits stay in your pocket. This is particularly important for active traders who can see a substantial portion of their profits eroded by brokerage fees with other brokers.
🔸 Encourages Active Trading: With no brokerage costs to worry about, traders can be more active in the market, executing more trades without the concern of fees cutting into their profits.
🔸 Simplifies Cost Management: With zero brokerage, you don’t have to calculate and manage additional trading costs, making it easier to manage your finances and understand your net returns.
🔸 Ideal for Beginners: For new traders who are still learning and experimenting with different strategies, zero brokerage reduces the financial pressure, allowing them to focus on learning without worrying about accumulating high trading costs.
Superior Support and Accessibility
Navia excels in providing superior customer support and accessibility compared to Zerodha. This is particularly beneficial for traders who value responsive and convenient support.
🔹 WhatsApp and Live Chat Support: Navia offers support through WhatsApp and live chat, whereas Zerodha does not. Additionally, Navia provides 24/7/365 chatbot support, making it easier for clients to get assistance at any time.
🔹 More Comprehensive EXE Platform: Navia offers a dedicated desktop platform (Navia EXE) along with a comprehensive API for algorithmic trading, whereas Zerodha lacks a desktop platform.
Expanded Product Offerings
Navia provides access to a broader range of products and services that cater to a wider array of investor needs.
🔹 Margin Trade Funding (MTF): Navia offers MTF with interest rates starting from 14.99%, which is not available with Zerodha. This feature can be crucial for traders looking to leverage their positions.
🔹 Access to US Stocks: Navia allows clients to trade US stocks, a feature that is not available with Zerodha. This gives Navia clients the ability to diversify their portfolios internationally.
Enhanced Trading Features
Navia provides additional trading features that can enhance the trading experience and potentially improve trading outcomes.
🔹 Results Calendar and Free ETF Baskets: Navia offers a results calendar and free ready-made and custom ETF baskets, which are not available with Zerodha. These features can help investors stay informed and make better investment decisions.
🔹 Single margin for Equity and Commodity: One significant advantage of Navia over other platforms like Zerodha is its single margin for Equity and Commodities. This feature allows traders who are active in both segments to maintain a single margin, eliminating the need to keep separate funds for each segment. As a result, clients benefit from better capital flexibility and more efficient utilization of funds, enabling them to seamlessly switch between equity and commodity trades without the hassle of managing two separate margin accounts. This not only streamlines the trading process but also maximizes capital efficiency for traders.
🔹 Single and Multi-Select Square Off Buttons: Navia provides single and multi-select square-off buttons, as well as a share screen option, making it easier to manage and monitor trades efficiently.
(All Figures mentioned in this blog are as on the date of publishing.)
DISCLAIMER: Investments in the securities market are subject to market risks, read all the related documents carefully before investing. The securities quoted are exemplary and are not recommendatory. Brokerage will not exceed the SEBI prescribed limit
We’d Love to Hear from you
